Talk:Sarah Shephard's lover

From Lostpedia

Contents 1 Christian Shephard 2 He Is Dead 3 Back to her old flame 4 Definetley Not Most of Those 5 Picture 6 They are not the same guy 7 Who are the actors 8 pregnant: who is the father 9 A Theory

Christian Shephard

I undid an edit which said that Christian Shephard was the lover of Sarah according to the DVD commentary. Now I think I might actually remember that, but I think it needs to be confirmed. Where is it said exactly in the commentary? Number 23 15:00, 21 June 2008 (PDT)

He Is Dead

Oh yeah, my bad. It doesn't stop that fact that they may have been in the same car though. Thanks for clearing that up :-) - Welshy 11:38, 20 August 2006 (PDT)

Back to her old flame

Is it possible shes gone back to her old flame?

He had a history with her, they were to be married and very possibly she doesn't know what he said to Jack about her being able to make love.

So he could be back on the scene and ideal to lure her away from Jack.

The other thing is that Jack, for all his stalking, doesnt seem to have got much info on the guy or is even sure if the man he sees waiting for her is the guy.

It possible that the guys shes seen with are minders for her.. to protect her from Jack.

--MRNasher

Definetley Not Most of Those

Okay, the guy isn't that hard to identify, and he's definetley not most of the characters listed in theories... --Sauron18 20:50, 14 October 2006 (PDT)

What do you mean not that hard to identify? If he's so easy, who is it? --Minderbinder 11:49, 15 October 2006 (PDT)

Actually...how do we know it's either of those two guys we saw in the episode? - It's obviously definately not one of them, so I reckon it's neither: one is simply a guy she was sharing a joke with and through Jack's eyes it seemed much closer and emotional and the other guy might be a family friend that Jack doesn't know of that picked her up so that Sarah didn't have to have her lover anywhere near Jack. Simple. I think it's still one of the ones on the list. --Andyroo316 14:23, 15 October 2006 (PDT)

Totally agree. It wouldn't make any sense that she would be so secretive about who she had an affair with, but then bring the guy along for Jack to see in person. --Minderbinder 05:40, 16 October 2006 (PDT)

Actually it kind of makes sense. Jack had just been arrested for attacking his own father. If you were involved with Sarah and she insisted on going to jail to bail her angry husband out wouldn't you demand to go with her on the off chance Jack loses it and attacks her like he did her father? Better he should attack you for being there than attack Sarah. user: ksofen666

Lol, doesn't te guy on the left look like Tony Hawk? --Marik7772003 17:05, 19 October 2006 (PDT)

Picture

I don't think the picture for this page should be there. As Andyroo has said we do not know know the identity of Sarah's lover. That guy could be anyone. Princess Dharma (banned)

They are not the same guy

These two guys are not the same.

It was my first impression and because of the complex lighting situation (bright sun and streetlight) I checked ceveral screenshots and now I'm dead sure those men are two different guys. You can rest your brains, my friends. If you need it I can post the SSs which proved it to me. The Eye 14:53, 26 February 2007 (PST)

Thank you Captain Obvious.--CaptainInsano 16:19, 26 February 2007 (PST)

Well Captain Sarcastic, never mind then. The Eye 17:13, 26 February 2007 (PST)

Who are the actors

The guy Sarah chatted with at the elementary school [1][2][3][4] resembles actor Michael Buchman Silver [5][6] (who has had recurring roles in “NYPD Blue”, “ER”, and “CSI:Miami”). --Kuzak 03:00, 28 May 2007 (PDT)

pregnant: who is the father

Do we actually know that the father of her unborn child in the S3 finale is the same guy as the one for which she left Jack? --DJVok 08:08, 4 December 2007 (PST)

• • • Nope. I can think of several other options.

1. Sarah left Jack for another man. Then she slept with yet another man and got pregnant (once a cheater always a cheater).

2. Sarah is a lesbian. Her baby was conceived via artificial insemination.

3. Sarah and Jack had one time reunion sex which resulted in a pregnancy and Sarah went back to her new man.

4. Sarah never cheated. Again her baby is conceived via artificial insemination.

5. Sarah was raped and became pregnant.

Granted some of these options are pretty silly but I don't think we can rule any of them out.

--Meteor

A Theory

Could Ben have been Sarah Shephard's lover?

In "The Other Woman", Harper tells Juliet that she looks just like another woman that Ben cares or cared about. In a previous episode, Ben asked Jack if he noticed how Juliet looked like Sarah.