Talk:Montand

From Lostpedia

Seriously the funniest theory

I do not think that just because each one of these three men lost their arms that they lost these arms at the same time in the same incident. Even if they are related (a virus that starts in the hand or something) it does not have to be at the SAME TIME...

I suppose the men would have been standing in a triangular pattern around an explosion, each facing to the side???

Also I do not understand the tie of the australian man (Ray, from Kate's flashback) to the Island. This has been suggested in Ray Mullen's discussion as well.. - cogito_ergo

At one point it was suggested that all of these three were also related to eachother, only because they had only one hand. Personally I find the theory a bit offensive, that all amputees know eachother and lost their respective members at the same time. But... if someone wants to keep the theory there even if there's no base to it, all the same to me. --skks 04:35, 15 April 2006 (PDT)

Montand = Candle ?

Maby Montand is another name for Marvin Candle , both lost one arm.