Artificial Environment (theory)

From Lostpedia

Fanon Alert!
This article contains tribute art, spin-off fiction, theories, reference and community material created by fans inspired by the show.
It is by definition non-canon, but generally distinct from intentionally fake hoaxes or humorous fan parody material.

... like in "The Truman Show".

Pros

The whole island seems to be staged.
- There are strange Stations with equipment inconsistencies (Computers from the 70s and Washing Machines from the 90s).
  - However, many places have equipment of varying eras: for example, most homes have an early-to-mid-1900s fireplace, a modern computer, mid-90s refrigerator and a mid 1900s water-tank.
- Animals that are out of place roam around.
- No planes or ships are ever to be seen, the stars are not real, the tides behave strangely.
- This could just be a production element, as the filmmakers might have wanted to convey how remote the island is (by showing a lot of stars in the sky).
- "The Others" wear theatrical disguises.
The Island is seemingly big but uninhabited.

Cons

Doesn't explain the dreams/visions.
Doesn't really explain the Security System.
Other than that, it is hard to find arguments (see VR/Dreamstate theory [1]), unless someone messes up and gives away the deception.
Inconsistencies could also be unintentional.
This theory has been dismissed by one of the makers of Lost (Carlton Cuse).
This theory is almost certainly wrong now that we have seen the listening station.
- Alternately, given the DHARMA Initiative's rather secretive nature it seems likely that if such an environment did exist, it would be exceptionally difficult to locate.
The Island appears staged because it is staged, by the cast and crew.